The hunt for a truly opaque black tight that survives a full workday without a run, snaps back after washing, and doesn’t turn sheer in the thigh is a specific kind of frustration. You need a tight that delivers consistent density from waist to ankle.
I’m Rikta — the founder and writer behind FitlyFast. I spend my time analyzing fabric denier readings, waistband construction, and real-world durability reports to separate the genuinely thick from the merely dark.
This guide breaks down the top contenders for solid coverage and lasting wear. My goal is to help you find the absolute best black tights that fit your body, your wardrobe, and your tolerance for mid-day snags.
How To Choose The Best Black Tights
Choosing a pair of black tights means looking past the basic color. The real performance lies in a few key specs that determine whether you get total coverage or a frustrating sheerness at the end of the day.
Denier: The Shortcut to True Opacity
The denier (D) number is your single best predictor of coverage. A 40D tight is semi-sheer, while a 70D to 90D tight delivers that solid, uniform black finish. For winter warmth and no-compromise opacity, look for tights at the higher end of this range.
Fit, Stretch, and the Control Top
A high-waisted control top can smooth your midsection, but the waistband needs to stay put without rolling or cutting in. Look for a wide, stretchy band and pay close attention to size charts that use weight and height, not just generic S/M/L. A tight fit prevents sheerness, but too-tight can be uncomfortable.
Fabric and Durability
Nylon and spandex blends offer classic stretch and recovery, while cotton-blend tights provide breathability and a softer hand feel. The densest tights in the 90D range are the most resistant to runs and snags, making them ideal for everyday wear. Check reviews for mentions of snagging on long nails or with rings.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanes EcoSmart Sheer Toe Blackout | Premium Nylon | Superior Warmth & Coverage | Blackout Opaque Density | Amazon |
| No nonsense Super Opaque Control Top | 90 Denier | Maximum Opaque Durability | 90 Denier Construction | Amazon |
| No nonsense Shapes High Waist | Shaping Control | Tummy Smoothing & Support | High Waist Control Band | Amazon |
| MeMoi Brooklyn Flat Knit Cotton | Cotton Knit | Nylon-Free Warmth | Cotton Sweater Knit Fabric | Amazon |
| Citystl 2 Pairs Plus Size Opaque | 80D Opaque | Budget-Friendly 2-Pack Value | 80D Microfiber Build | Amazon |
| UISLII Plus Size 2 Pairs 80D Semi Opaque | Plus Size 6XL | Extended Plus Sizes (Up to 6XL) | 80D Soft Microfiber | Amazon |
| SHAPERMINT High-Waisted Shapewear Shorts | Smoothing Shorts | Chafe Prevention & Light Shaping | Buttery Soft Compression | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Hanes EcoSmart Sheer Toe, Blackout Opaque Tights
The Hanes EcoSmart delivers a dense, blackout-level opaque finish that reviewers consistently describe as “thick and great quality.” Multiple users report these surviving several wears without a single rip or snag, a rarity in the tights category, and they specifically note the warmth makes them ideal for cold-weather wear and even plane rides as a base layer.
The high-waisted band is cited as comfortable and stays put, and the sheer-toe design adds versatility. One long-time user appreciates the quality but flags the price as on the higher side for a base layer, while another notes that sizing up is a smart move for a perfect fit. The overall durability rating from verified buyers is very strong.
If you prioritize a truly opaque look and want a pair that can handle real daily wear without falling apart, the Hanes EcoSmart is a reliable premium choice. The trade-off is a higher entry cost, but the reports of no rips and sustained quality across multiple wears justify the investment for many.
Why it’s great
- Strong blackout opaque coverage rated highly
- Excellent durability with no reported rips
- Comfortable high-waisted band
Good to know
- Higher price point for a base layer
- Sizing up is recommended for best fit
2. No nonsense Women’s Super Opaque Control Top Tights 90 Denier
The 90 denier construction of these No nonsense tights is the standout feature, delivering a very dense and opaque finish that users confirm is nearly bulletproof. Reviews frequently mention no snags or runs even with long nails, a reinforced toe, and a waistband that stays firmly in place without slipping, all at a very accessible mid-range price point.
Multiple verified buyers describe them as “very dense” and “awesome,” with one noting they size down for a perfect fit. The main caveat from detailed feedback is that the opaque coverage can become slightly see-through in daylight or on a “big butt,” so sizing up to the 2XL for better opacity is a smart strategy for curvier figures.
These tights are the practical choice for someone who values absolute density and extreme durability over softness or a shaping effect. They feel strong and are proven to withstand multiple wears, but the trade-off is a slightly shiny finish and a control band that can be snug on the midsection.
Why it’s great
- Extremely durable with zero reported runs
- Genuinely dense 90 denier fabric
- Reinforced toe and reliable waistband
Good to know
- Can be slightly see-through in daylight for some sizes
- Control band may feel snug on the midsection
3. No nonsense Women’s Shapes High Waist Tights
These No nonsense tights shift focus from sheer density to targeted shaping, featuring a high-waisted control band that rises to the lower ribs for serious tummy smoothing. A reviewer at 5’4″ and 230 lbs confirms the band tucks the tummy in nicely without pinching, and another at 5’7″ and 215 lbs in an XXL says they “hate tights but likes these enough to buy more colors.”
The fabric is near-opaque and well-made, but users note it becomes slightly sheer at the upper thighs. The legs run a bit long, which can cause bunching at the ankle for shorter wearers — a factor to consider. The shaping effect is real, offering light to moderate compression without being overly restrictive, and the waistband stays put without rolling.
This is the pick for anyone who needs a control top that actually delivers smoothing without discomfort. The trade-off is a slightly looser fit in the leg and a touch of sheerness at the very top, but the shaping results earn it a loyal following.
Why it’s great
- Effective high-waisted tummy control
- Comfortable for long wear, no pinching
- Wide band stays secure without rolling
Good to know
- Can be slightly sheer at the upper thighs
- Legs run long, may bunch at the ankle
4. MeMoi Brooklyn Flat Knit Cotton Tights, Cozy Sweater Tights
These MeMoi tights offer a completely different experience from standard nylon hosiery, made from a thick, cotton flat-knit that feels more like a soft sweater. Multiple reviews emphasize the material as “incredibly thick and warm” and note it is perfect for those allergic to nylon, offering a cozy, durable alternative that resists runs and tears.
The knit fabric is stretchy but holds its shape well, and one reviewer with wide hips notes it fits great without digging in. The main downside is the fit: the high rise goes up to the bra line, requiring adjustment for shorter torsos (5’4″ reviewers mention it’s “so long”). The heathered cotton texture is also slightly see-through, so these are best for colder-weather layering.
If you want cotton or need a nylon-free option, this is the standout choice. The trade-off is a very long rise and a fabric that is too warm for moderate weather, but for pure comfort and a legging-like feel, these are a category of their own.
Why it’s great
- Extremely thick, warm, and cozy material
- Excellent alternative for nylon allergies
- Durable knit resists runs
Good to know
- Very long rise, requires adjustment on shorter torsos
- Fabric is slightly see-through in daylight
5. Citystl 2 Pairs Plus Size Tights, 80D Opaque Black
Citystl delivers a solid budget-friendly package with a two-pack of 80D opaque tights that reviewers rate highly for their comfortable fit and dark coverage. Verified buyers note they stay up without rolling down, are not itchy, and survive multiple washes without developing runs or holes — a strong performance for the price.
The wide waistband and good stretch are praised on curvy figures, and one reviewer at 5’2″ and 190 lbs confirms the fit is true to size without pinching. The 80D fabric is thick but not overly warm, and while it is described as “very black,” some users note it is not perfectly 100% opaque in the most direct light, making it a great everyday choice rather than a full-blackout tight.
For a two-pack at an entry-level price, the Citystl offers surprising durability and color fastness. If you need a reliable, comfortable daily wear tight without the investment of a premium single pair, this is your best bet. The minor trade-off is that 80D may not be as dense as a 90D tight.
Why it’s great
- Great value for two pairs
- High durability with no runs after washing
- Comfortable, slip-resistant waistband
Good to know
- 80D is not fully blackout opaque
- Some users mention a vertical front seam
6. UISLII Plus Size Tights 2 Pairs, 80D Semi Opaque, Up to 6XL
These UISLII tights are built specifically for the plus-size market, with sizing that goes up to 6XL and a design that caters to bodies with more hips, thighs, and backside. A reviewer wearing a clothes size 22-24 in the 5X-6X option confirms they “fit perfectly,” are “thick and soft,” and “not see-through,” earning a strong recommendation.
The fabric is consistently praised as “super soft” and durable, with users noting they withhold tearing better than other brands. One detailed review from a 5’4″, 244 lb user in XXL notes the tights are “very long” with extra fabric, but gives high marks for durability, not running, staying up, and being comfortable. The color also matches skin tones well for a natural look.
If you are in the plus-size range and struggle to find tights that offer true opaque density and a soft feel without digging in, these are a top contender. The main consideration is the length; they are clearly designed for taller bodies, so shorter plus-size wearers may have to manage extra fabric at the ankle.
Why it’s great
- Extended sizing up to 6XL fits well
- Very soft, thick, and not see-through
- Durable and resists tearing
Good to know
- Very long legs, may be too long for shorter wearers
- 80D is semi-opaque, not fully blackout
7. SHAPERMINT High-Waisted Shapewear Tummy Control Shorts, Thigh Slimmer
The SHAPERMINT shorts are not traditional tights but a dedicated shapewear layer designed to be worn underneath dresses and skirts for a smooth, chafe-free foundation. Reviews highlight the “buttery soft” and stretchy fabric that is easy to put on, and a grippy wave at the bottom that prevents the legs from digging in or rolling up — a common issue with shapewear shorts.
One user at 5’11” and 310 lbs in a 3X/4X finds the shorts comfortable with light to moderate compression that smoothes her silhouette under clingy dresses and provides abdominal support. However, another reviewer at 5’2″, 150 lbs describes it as “smoothing, not shaping,” noting it does not suck in a mom pouch but simply smooths lumps. The legs can ride up with frequent movement for some.
If your primary need is friction prevention and a smooth silhouette under form-fitting dresses without strong compression, these work well. They are not a replacement for high-compression shaping, but they are a premium-feeling, comfortable base layer that eliminates VPL and chafing.
Why it’s great
- Buttery soft, stretchy, and comfortable fabric
- Grippy wave band prevents rolling
- Effective for smoothing and chafe protection
Good to know
- Provides light smoothing, not strong compression
- Legs may ride up with frequent walking/sitting
FAQ
What denier is best for truly opaque black tights?
How do I stop my black tights from rolling down?
Can I get black tights that are safe for nylon allergies?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best black tights winner is the Hanes EcoSmart Sheer Toe Blackout Opaque Tights because it delivers the best balance of genuine blackout coverage, exceptional durability, and warmth in a trusted brand. If you want absolute denier density and a proven track record of no runs, grab the No nonsense 90 Denier Super Opaque Control Top Tights. And for a cozy, nylon-free feel ideal for colder months, the MeMoi Brooklyn Flat Knit Cotton Tights are unmatched.