Reader support keeps this site open, opinionated, and happily independent. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.7 Best Avocado Oil Mayonnaise | Rich Mayo Without Soy or Canola

Check Price on Amazon

Primal Kitchen has set the benchmark for avocado oil mayonnaise with a formula that uses avocado oil as the primary fat source and cage-free eggs for a thick, stable emulsion. The tangy flavor is slightly more pronounced than traditional mayo, which reviewers consistently praise for elevating tuna salad, turkey burgers, and deviled eggs. It carries the Whole30 Approved, Certified Paleo, and Keto Certified seals, making it one of the most diet-inclusive options on the shelf.

The 24-ounce jar represents substantial value for a mid-range product, though some buyers note that shipping in hot or cold weather can cause the emulsion to separate. Customer reports describe a strong avocado taste that pairs well with bold ingredients like chipotle or lemon juice. One reviewer adds a dollop of full-fat Greek yogurt and lemon to mellow the intensity without losing the creamy base.

Several long-term users mention that recent production batches have shown separation issues not present in earlier orders, with oil pooling on top. Primal Kitchen’s customer support acknowledges this as a transit challenge and offers partial refunds, but it’s worth inspecting the jar upon arrival. Despite this consistency variable, it remains the top pick for its clean ingredient deck and balanced flavor.

Check Price on Amazon

Chosen Foods achieves a smooth, rich emulsion without any eggs by relying on chickpea broth and faba bean protein. The result is a vegan-friendly mayonnaise that holds its own against egg-based competitors in both texture and flavor. It is certified Non-GMO, gluten-free, dairy-free, and kosher, making it an accessible choice for restrictive diets. The slightly tangy finish comes from vinegar, mustard, and spices rather than artificial additives.

This 24-fluid ounce jar is priced solidly in the mid-range territory, and customer feedback emphasizes its excellent stability during shipping compared to other vegan mayos. The cold weather warning still applies, but reviewers report fewer separation incidents than with egg-based brands. Users with soy allergies frequently name this as their go-to replacement for conventional sandwich spreads.

Some users note that the texture is slightly less thick than traditional egg mayo, but it still works well for dressings, coleslaw, and potato salad. One reviewer accidentally ordered this instead of the regular Chosen Foods mayo but ended up preferring the vegan version for its lighter, cleaner finish. The kosher certification adds appeal for those who need that verification.

Check Price on Amazon

This two-pack gives you one jar of Primal Kitchen’s Original Mayo and one jar of Chipotle Lime Mayo, offering variety without committing to a full 24-ounce single flavor. The Chipotle Lime variant brings a mild smoky heat and citrus brightness that works especially well on tacos, chicken sandwiches, and as a dip for fries. Both versions share the same clean base of avocado oil and cage-free eggs, with no soy, canola, or artificial sweeteners.

The original formula has a creamy, slightly tangy profile that reviewers consistently describe as “homemade quality.” One long-time user reports that guests always compliment their egg salad without realizing the secret ingredient is Primal Kitchen Mayo. The packaging of this two-pack is notable — the cardboard multi-box holder protects the glass jars effectively during shipping, a detail that addresses the separation concerns seen with single-jar shipments.

A small number of buyers experienced an initial rancid taste in the Chipotle Lime variant, which the manufacturer explained as a stronger vinegar-forward profile compared to commercial mayo. After adjusting to the flavor, most users report it becomes a kitchen staple. If you want to test chipotle versions without buying a full-sized jar, this combo is a smart entry point.

Check Price on Amazon

Sir Kensington’s uses 100% avocado oil and adds a squeeze of lime and a pinch of black pepper, giving this mayo a subtle citrus and spice lift without being overpowering. The squeeze bottle format is a practical advantage over jar-based competitors, making it easier to apply directly to sandwiches or burgers without dirtying a knife. It is Paleo and Keto Diet Certified, with no sugar and no artificial preservatives.

Customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with some reviewers calling it the “GOAT of mayonnaise” and noting that it improves the flavor of grilled meats and deviled eggs significantly. The creaminess lands somewhere between homemade and commercial — thick enough to hold its shape but still easy to spread. The 2-pack of 12-ounce bottles is priced in the mid-range, offering a good balance between unit cost and convenience.

The cold weather warning applies equally here; bottles can separate if exposed to freezing temperatures during transit. A small number of users report that the nozzle can clog when adding ingredients like relish, but tapping the bottle on the counter usually clears it. Overall, it’s a strong pick for those who prioritize an easy-to-use package and a lighter, peppery flavor profile.

Check Price on Amazon

Ayoh! is a relatively new entrant developed by chef and food creator Molly Baz, aiming to reimagine sandwich sauces with a bold, flavor-first philosophy. This starter pack includes Dill Pickle Mayo and Hot Giardinayo, both made with avocado oil and free from seed oils and artificial stabilizers. The Dill Pickle variant delivers a tangy, briny hit that pairs naturally with tuna sandwiches and burgers, while the Hot Giardinayo brings a spicy, vinegary kick ideal for subs and wraps.

Customer reviews highlight the uniqueness of the flavors — one user describes the Hot Giardinayo as having a “delicious zip” that makes egg sandwiches exciting, while the Dill Pickle is praised for its thick, spreadable consistency. The texture is noticeably thicker than standard avocado mayos, which works well for spreading but makes it harder to use as a dip for fries or nuggets. The two-pack comes in 12-ounce jars, placing it at a premium price point.

A small number of buyers encountered consistency issues, with one reporting that the Dill Pickle mayo arrived looking like chopped pickles in water rather than a creamy emulsion. Ayoh! acknowledges that natural separation can occur without artificial stabilizers, especially during extreme temperature shifts. If you enjoy experimenting with bold condiment flavors, this pack offers something genuinely different from the standard avocado mayo category.

Check Price on Amazon

RON DEYMOND offers the largest single-jar quantity in this lineup at 32 ounces, making it a practical choice for households that go through mayonnaise quickly. The formula is built on 100% avocado oil and is free from soy, canola, dairy, and gluten. It is also Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher, appealing to buyers who prioritize label simplicity. The listed units suggest it is produced with RON DEYMOND’s manufacturing standards.

Customer feedback highlights that this is one of the few store-bought mayos with truly no seed oils — a point that resonates with health-conscious shoppers who have researched how many “avocado oil” brands still use soy as a primary ingredient. The flavor is described as clean and slightly tangy, though one reviewer notes that the inclusion of water in the ingredient list makes it runnier than traditional egg mayo, which can throw off recipes that rely on a thick binder.

Some concerns have been raised about packaging and labeling — the brand is less established than Primal Kitchen or Sir Kensington’s, and one buyer found the kosher stamp to look unofficial. The tub format is less convenient for dispensing than a squeeze bottle, and the seal may not be perfectly airtight after opening. Despite these minor drawbacks, it delivers the highest volume per dollar within the clean-ingredient avocado mayo segment.

Check Price on Amazon

This six-pack bundles Sir Kensington’s 12-ounce squeeze bottles for those who want to stock multiple kitchens, save on per-unit cost, or simply avoid running out mid-week. Each bottle contains the same 100% avocado oil formula with lime and black pepper that earned individual rave reviews. The bulk format effectively brings the unit cost down, making this the most economical way to access a premium avocado oil mayo brand.

Long-term users are highly loyal to this product, with one reviewer stating they have bought it for years and regularly recommend it to others. The flavor is consistently described as superior to Hellmann’s or Best Foods, with a creamy richness that works well in shrimp salad, coleslaw, and sandwich spreads. The squeeze bottle design remains a practical advantage — no scooping, no knife scraping, just direct application.

The main trade-off is the premium per-ounce price compared to bulk economy brands, even with the six-pack discount. The cold weather separation risk still applies to these plastic bottles, though the smaller individual units are easier to store in a refrigerator door. If you already know you like Sir Kensington’s flavor and want to secure a long-term supply, this pack offers the best value within the brand.