Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
That craving for a perfect black and white cookie — half vanilla icing, half chocolate, on a soft cake base — is easy to have. But ordering online is a gamble: you might get a dry crumb or a smashed box. This guide helps you pick a cookie that actually tastes like the deli classic you are after, if you need a few for yourself or a tin for a gift. The pick for most people is the Best Cookies 5″ 24-Count — 24 individually wrapped jumbo cookies at 6 pounds total, so you get a real New York deli bite for a reasonable per-cookie cost, no stale surprises.
I share what I have learned from looking at the specs and reading what real buyers report, so you know the strengths and trade-offs of each option.
From jumbo singles to holiday tins, these are the best black and white cookies you can reliably get delivered without the disappointment of a broken cookie or stale icing.
Quick Picks
- Best Cookies 5″ Black and White Cookies New York Style – 24 Count — Best Overall
- Hanukkah Cookie Gift Basket, Decorated Colored Black And Whites, Kosher – 18 Count — Best Gift
- Christmas Cookies, Decorated Black And White Cookies In Tin, Gourmet – 18 Count — Christmas Pick
- Stern’s Bakery Black and White Cookies – 20 Gourmet Cookies Individually Wrapped — Best for Pantry
- Stern’s Bakery Black and White Cookies – 10 Count, NY Style, Mini — Budget Mini
- Kosherbyte Black & White Cookies – 3 Jumbo Cookies — Taste Test
How To Choose The Best Black And White Cookies
Every black and white cookie starts with a soft, cake-like vanilla base and a two-tone icing top. But the difference between a great one and a letdown depends on three things: freshness at arrival, the quality of the icing, and the size-to-price ratio. Here is what to watch for when you are buying online.
Shipping and Packaging — The Number One Failure Point
More buyers complain about crushed cookies than the taste. A cookie in a flimsy plastic clamshell or a box shipped loose in a poly bag often arrives as crumbs. Look for tins or rigid boxes that keep the cookies from sliding around. Individually wrapped cookies fare better in transit because each one is protected by its own wrapper.
Icing Texture and Flavor Balance
The vanilla side should taste mildly sweet, and the chocolate side should have a real cocoa flavor — not just sugary fondant. Buyers frequently note that cookies with a thin, gummy, or overly sweet icing miss the mark. A good cookie has a thick, set icing that does not stick to the wrapper.
Portion Size vs. Cookie Count
A pack advertising 10 cookies might weigh only 8 or 10 ounces total, meaning each cookie is small. If you want a substantial deli-style cookie, check the total weight: a 4-ounce jumbo cookie is a different experience than a 0.8-ounce mini. Match the size to your use — mini for snacking, jumbo for that classic bakery feel.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Count | Total Weight | Individually Wrapped | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best Cookies 5″ (24 Count) | Bulk snacking / long-term stash | 24 | 6 lbs | Yes | $69.99Amazon |
| Hanukkah Cookie Gift Basket | Festive gifting / holiday table | 18 | 1.79 lbs | No | $39.99Amazon |
| Christmas Cookies Tin | Holiday gift presentation | 18 | 1.76 lbs | No | $42.99Amazon |
| Stern’s 20 Count | Pantry / lunchbox prep | 20 | 1.5 lbs | Yes | $27.99Amazon |
| Stern’s 10 Count | Mini snack / portion control | 10 | 10 oz | No | $20.99Amazon |
| Kosherbyte 3 Count | Taste test / single craving | 3 | 4 oz | No | $12.95Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Best Cookies 5″ Black and White Cookies New York Style – 24 Count
$69.99as of Jul 5, 12:05 AM24 individually wrapped cookies at 5 inches each — far bigger and heavier per cookie than the Stern’s 20-count, which weighs only 1.5 pounds total for nearly the same number.
You get the classic soft vanilla cake base topped with one half chocolate icing and one half vanilla icing, and each cookie is sealed so it stays fresh for weeks. Owners mention that storing them in the fridge keeps the icing from sticking to the wrapper, a small trick that solves the common complaint with other packs. Unlike the Stern’s 20-count which weighs only 1.5 pounds for nearly the same number of cookies, these are 4 times heavier per cookie — a massive gap that shows up in the first bite.
One reviewer noted the cookies are “cost-effective vs. deli” and worth re-ordering, though they cautioned that the packaging is not fancy enough for gifting. The 5-inch size means each cookie provides a substantial, filling snack, not a dainty tea biscuit.
Why these win
- 5-inch jumbo size matches the classic NYC bakery experience
- Individually wrapped for freshness and easy portion control
- 6 pounds total — unbeatable value for the weight per dollar
One thing to know
- Not gift-ready — plain packaging, no tin or box presentation
Reach for this if: you want a stockpile of big, authentic-tasting cookies that stay fresh for weeks and deliver the closest thing to a bakery counter at a better per-cookie cost than a deli.
Look elsewhere if: you need a pretty gift box or have just one cookie craving — this is a commitment.
2. Hanukkah Cookie Gift Basket, Decorated Colored Black And Whites, Kosher – 18 Count
$39.99as of Jul 5, 12:05 AMThe sturdy tin and hand-decorated icing make this a winner for gifting, unlike the plain bags or flimsy boxes other picks use.
These are not your standard black and whites. The bakers hand-decorate 6 of the 18 cookies with Hanukkah-themed designs and color the remaining 12 in blue and white icing, all inside a durable gift tin. The cookies are certified kosher by CRC (a recognized kosher certification agency) and weigh 1.79 pounds total, a 19% heavier package than the Stern’s 20-count at 1.5 pounds, so each cookie has more substance. One reviewer called these “some of the best cookies I’ve ever tasted,” highlighting the soft, fresh texture and careful decoration. The tin also makes this a safer bet for shipping compared to the flimsy plastic boxes that arrive crushed — reviewers consistently praise the presentation.
The trade-off is that the decorative icing makes these more of a specialty item than a daily snack. If you want plain black and whites for your own pantry, the simpler packs below are better. But for a gift that impresses before it is even opened, this is the standout.
What stands out
- Beautifully decorated with themed icing — Hanukkah-specific designs
- Solid tin protects cookies during shipping, arrives intact
- Buyers rave about the taste and freshness
The catch
- Seasonal decorating limits its year-round appeal
- Not individually wrapped, so eat them within a few days of opening
Best for gifting: arrive in a beautiful tin and taste fresh and soft — a Hanukkah gift that will actually get eaten.
Skip if: you want plain black and whites for everyday snacking.
3. Christmas Cookies, Decorated Black And White Cookies In Tin, Gourmet – 18 Count
$42.99as of Jul 5, 12:05 AMHandmade in NYC and packed in a sturdy tin, these 2.5-inch cookies are a compact Christmas gift — but check them fast because customers note some batches arrive stale.
Like the Hanukkah set, these are hand-decorated and packed in a sturdy gift tin, but with Christmas-themed red and white icing. Each cookie is 2.5 inches across, which is a moderate size — larger than the Stern’s 10-count minis but smaller than the 5-inch jumbos above. The package dimensions are 8.62 x 5.79 x 2.72 inches, a 22% smaller box than the Stern’s 20-count, which makes the tin compact enough for a stocking or gift bag.
Buyers generally love the presentation and taste — several call them “festive and delicious” — but there is a notable risk: one buyer mentioned buying two tins that arrived stale and had to be thrown away, saying the cookies were “unacceptable” for their grandchildren. If you order these, plan to open the tin immediately and check the texture so you can act fast if something is off.
Why it works
- Handmade in NYC with a soft, cake-like texture
- Tin protects cookies from crushing in transit
- Festive red and white icing looks great on a holiday table
One real risk
- Some batches arrived stale — freshness is not guaranteed on every order
Reach for this if: you need a Christmas gift that looks beautiful in a tin and matches the New York style your recipient will recognize.
Proceed with caution if: you cannot inspect the cookies immediately after delivery — staleness is a reported issue.
4. Stern’s Bakery Black and White Cookies – 20 Gourmet Cookies Individually Wrapped
$27.99as of Jul 5, 12:05 AM20 individually wrapped cookies at 1.5 pounds total are convenient for lunchboxes, but the flimsy plastic box and poly bag often arrive crushed — a big drop in reliability versus the Best Cookies 24-count at 6 pounds in proper packaging.
With 20 cookies at 1.5 pounds total, these are individually wrapped, which is practical for grabbing one on the way out the door or packing in a school lunch. The 25-ounce unit size is a full 3.1x larger than the 10-count Stern’s pack at 8 ounces, so you get a lot more cookie per package. Buyers like the taste — one simply calls them “tasty” — but the shipping experience is a recurring complaint.
The packaging is a “flimsy plastic box wrapped in saran wrap shipped in a bag,” as one reviewer put it, and the cookies often arrive crushed with frosting stuck to the cellophane. Another reviewer notes the cookies are “a bit dry” and recommends refrigerating them immediately. The concept is right, but the packaging does not protect the product well enough for a reliable experience.
The upside
- Individually wrapped — perfect for on-the-go snacking
- Decent flavor that buyers enjoy
Where it falls short
- Packaging is flimsy — many orders arrive crushed or crumbled
- Cookies can be dry; keep them in the fridge to preserve texture
Go for it if: you want individually wrapped cookies and are willing to accept some shipping risk for the convenience of grab-and-go portions.
Pass if: you need a guaranteed intact arrival — choose a tin instead.
5. Stern’s Bakery Black and White Cookies – 10 Count, NY Style, Mini
$20.99as of Jul 5, 12:05 AMBuyers who got intact cookies praise the authentic New York taste — but about half the reviews mention damage from the unprotected clamshell shipping.
These are the smallest of the bunch — 10 mini cookies at a total of 10 ounces, which is a 2.5x heavier item weight than the 3-pack at 4 ounces, but still means each cookie is a light, snack-sized bite. Buyers who received intact cookies praise them as “fresh, light, not too sweet, and authentic to New York taste.” The mini size is popular for a bedtime snack or a low-commitment treat. One reviewer specifically noted they are “perfect size if you are watching your sugar intake.”
The problem is that they are not individually wrapped, and they ship in a clamshell container without enough padding. Multiple verified reviewers point out the cookies arriving “broken, messy and the chocolate guncked on” or “destroyed during shipping.” The taste is good, but about half the reviews mention damage, making this a gamble.
The good part
- Authentic New York flavor — buyers love the taste
- Mini size is great for a small treat or portion control
The bad part
- High risk of shipping damage — clamshell offers little protection
- Not individually wrapped, so one broken cookie affects the whole batch
Consider this if: you just want a small taste of a real NY black and white and are buying for yourself — not for a gift or event where appearance matters.
skip it if: you cannot afford the disappointment of a broken delivery.
6. Kosherbyte Black & White Cookies – 3 Jumbo Cookies
$12.95as of Jul 5, 12:05 AMEach of the 3 cookies is a jumbo 4-ounce size, so one cookie gives you a proper deli-style portion — more substance per bite than a mini from Stern’s 10-count.
This is a minimal commitment — just 3 cookies at 4 ounces total, but each cookie is a jumbo 4-ounce size, so you get a proper deli-style portion in each one. They are OU Kosher certified (certified by the Orthodox Union, meeting strict dietary standards) and the kind of cookie you would find served in New York restaurants. Buyers who love them say they “taste authentic, reminiscent of high-quality Jewish deli cookies” and that they “satisfy cravings for traditional pastries.” One happy recipient described hearing their father “drooling through the phone” while enjoying them as a pick-me-up.
The item weight of 4 ounces means the 3-pack is 2.5x lighter than the 10-count Stern’s pack, so you are paying for quality and freshness rather than quantity. However, one reviewer found them “too much like a cake” with no lemon flavor, so the texture leans toward the cakey side of the black-and-white spectrum. They are not individually wrapped, so freshness is tied to how quickly you eat them.
What works
- Jumbo 4-ounce cookies with authentic deli flavor
- OU Kosher certified — meets strict dietary standards
What does not
- Cake-like texture may disappoint those expecting a denser cookie
- No individual wrapping — eat them within a day or two of opening
For a single authentic taste of a New York deli cookie without committing to a large box, this 3-pack delivers. It is not the pick if you prefer a firm, chewy cookie over a soft, cakey one.
Understanding the Specs
Cookie Count vs. Total Weight
Do not pick by the number of cookies alone — a box of 10 cookies can weigh anywhere from 10 ounces to 6 pounds depending on the size of each cookie. The total weight in ounces or pounds tells you how much actual cookie you are getting. If you want a full deli-style experience, look for packs where the total weight is at least 1.5 pounds for a dozen cookies or more.
Individually Wrapped vs. Loose Pack
Individually wrapped cookies last longer in your pantry and protect each cookie from the others. Loose-packed cookies in a clamshell or tin are more likely to arrive broken, and once you open the package you need to eat them within a few days. For gifting, tins win on presentation; for everyday snacking, individual wrapping wins on freshness.
FAQ
Do black and white cookies need to be refrigerated?
How do I prevent black and white cookies from arriving broken?
Are Stern’s Bakery black and white cookies the same size as the Best Cookies brand?
Are any of these black and white cookies gluten free?
What makes a black and white cookie “New York style”?
Can I send black and white cookies as a gift?
How many cookies come in a typical black and white cookie pack?
Why do some black and white cookies taste stale when they arrive?
Are black and white cookies kosher certified?
What is the shelf life of an individually wrapped black and white cookie?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most buyers, the black and white cookies winner is the Best Cookies 5″ 24-Count because you get 24 individually wrapped jumbo cookies that taste like a New York deli classic and stay fresh for weeks — no broken tins, no stale surprises. If you need a beautiful gift that impresses on arrival, grab the Hanukkah Cookie Gift Basket for its decorated cookies and sturdy tin. And for a single authentic taste without a big commitment, the Kosherbyte 3-Count delivers that real deli flavor in a jumbo portion.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of July 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, FitlyFast earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED "AS IS" AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.