The problem is that many jars deliver a dry, crumbly cheese center or a bland olive that lacks the firm, buttery snap of a properly cured fruit. The right jar balances the saltiness of the brine with the rich, pungent creaminess of real blue cheese.
I’m Rikta — the co-founder and writer behind FitlyFast. I research the small-batch production methods, curing techniques, and cheese-to-olive ratios that separate a premium cocktail olive from an afterthought.
After tasting through brine-packed and oil-packed jars, evaluating cheese creaminess, olive firmness, and overall balance, I’ve identified the top contenders for the best blue cheese stuffed olives to keep your martini basket and snack board stocked.
How To Choose The Best Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives
The best jar doesn’t just have the biggest brand name — it has the right olive varietal, a creamy and flavorful cheese center, and a packing medium that matches your intended use. Here are the three factors that matter most when you’re shopping this category.
Olive Variety and Texture
Queen olives are the standard for stuffing because they are large, meaty, and have a firm texture that can withstand the fill. Halkidiki olives, from northern Greece, are even larger with a distinctively crisp crunch. A good Queen olive will have a buttery bite, while a Halkidiki provides a sharper snap. Avoid olives that feel mushy or have a rubbery skin — that indicates over-processing or poor curing.
Cheese Quality and Creaminess
The blue cheese inside should be creamy and not crumbly or dry. Real Wisconsin blue cheese, Roquefort, or Gorgonzola dolce all work well because they melt slightly at room temperature, creating a luxurious texture. Some mass-market brands use a mix of blue cheese and cream cheese to extend the filling — this can make the center too soft and mild. Look for jars that specifically call out the cheese type (e.g., “Real Wisconsin Blue Cheese”) and avoid fillers like modified food starch or cellulose.
Packing Medium: Brine vs. Oil
This is the most overlooked detail. Brine-packed olives are essential for Dirty Martinis because the brine adds saltiness and complexity to the drink. Oil-packed olives are designed for snacking and charcuterie boards — the olive oil softens the olive’s skin and enriches the flavor. If you buy oil-packed olives for a martini, you’ll get a greasy surface and a muted brine flavor. Always check the packaging: brine should list water, salt, and vinegar; oil should list extra virgin olive oil or sunflower oil.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Filthy Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives | Brine-Packed | Premium Dirty Martinis | Real Wisconsin Blue Cheese, 8.5 oz jar | Amazon |
| Divina Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives (2-Pack) | Brine-Packed | Everyday Martinis & Snacking | Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, 7.8 oz jar | Amazon |
| Tassos Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives | Oil-Packed | Charcuterie Boards & Snacking | Colossal Halkidiki Olives, 34.24 oz | Amazon |
| Santa Barbara Olive Co. Variety 3-Pack | Brine-Packed | Sampling & Entertaining | 3 Flavors per pack, 5 oz each | Amazon |
| Divina Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives (3-Pack) | Brine-Packed | Stocking Up for Martinis | Exact same recipe as 2-pack, 7.8 oz jar | Amazon |
| Filthy Martini Cocktail Kit | Brine-Packed Kit | Complete Martini Setup | Includes brine, picks, & both olive types | Amazon |
| Pearls Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives (6-Pack) | Brine-Packed | Bulk Buying for Home Bars | Halkidiki Queen Olives, 6.7 oz jar | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Filthy Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives
Filthy’s Queen olives are naturally cured to preserve a firm, buttery bite, and they are hand-stuffed with a rich, creamy Wisconsin blue cheese that doesn’t crumble when you bite. The brine is well-balanced — salty but not harsh — making it ideal for a Dirty Martini where the olive contributes both flavor and texture to the drink.
Each 8.5 oz jar contains 14 olives, which is a modest count, but the quality is undeniable. Customers repeatedly mention that the blue cheese is “creamy and potent” without being overpowering, and the olives themselves have a satisfying snap. The resealable jar keeps them fresh in the fridge between uses.
The only real complaint is portion size: at this price point, the jar feels small, especially if you’re serving a crowd. But for a premium cocktail garnish that brings bar-level quality to your home setup, Filthy delivers consistently.
Why it’s great
- Creamy, bold blue cheese that holds its texture
- Naturally cured olives with a firm, buttery bite
- Trusted by top bars and restaurants as a standard garnish
Good to know
- Only 14 olives per jar — disappears fast with multiple drinks
- Some customers find the price high relative to jar size
2. DIVINA Blue Cheese Stuffed Green Olives (2-Pack)
Divina uses Greek olives that are generously filled with a creamy, tangy blue cheese. The 2-pack gives you two 7.8 oz jars, which is a solid amount for the price range. The olives are satisfyingly crunchy, and the cheese-to-olive ratio is generous — you get a full, flavorful center in every bite.
Customers rave about the flavor balance, calling these “hands down the best mass-produced blue cheese stuffed olives” for Dirty Martinis. The olives are non-GMO and gluten-free, and they pack enough briny punch that you can use the liquid straight in a martini without additional brine.
The only downside is that a few reviewers wish the jars were larger. If you go through olives quickly, you might find yourself reaching for a third jar before the week is out. Still, for the price per ounce, this kit delivers excellent quality.
Why it’s great
- Excellent cheese-to-olive filling ratio
- Crunchy, firm Greek olives with great texture
- Non-GMO, gluten-free, and all-natural ingredients
Good to know
- Some customers wish jars were larger for frequent use
- Brine flavor is milder than some premium brands
3. Tassos Blue Cheese Stuffed Colossal Greek Olives
Tassos uses Colossal-sized Halkidiki olives from Greece, hand-stuffed with a blend of blue cheese and Mizithra — a Greek cheese that adds a slightly sweeter, nuttier finish. The 34.24 oz jar is a massive value, and the olives are packed in oil, not brine, which makes them ideal for snacking straight from the jar or adding to a charcuterie board.
Customers love the bold, sophisticated flavor profile and the satisfying crunch of the Halkidiki olive. This jar is perfect for keto and paleo diets since the olives are gluten-free, sugar-free, and low-carb. The oil can also be used as a salad dressing base or drizzled over eggs.
A key caveat: these are not martini olives. The oil coating mutes the brine flavor and can leave a greasy film on your drink. Several customers have warned against using them in cocktails, so reserve this jar for grazing and antipasti platters.
Why it’s great
- Colossal olives with a crisp, satisfying crunch
- Unique blue cheese/Mizithra blend for nuanced flavor
- Massive jar size great for parties and meal prep
Good to know
- Oil-packed — not suitable for Dirty Martinis
- Some orders arrive with leaking lids (non-returnable food item)
4. Santa Barbara Olive Co. 3-Pack (Garlic, Jalapeno & Blue Cheese)
This 3-pack from Santa Barbara Olive Co. includes one jar each of garlic-stuffed, jalapeno-stuffed, and blue cheese-stuffed olives (5 oz each). It’s a great way to sample different flavors without committing to a full-size jar of one type. The blue cheese version has a creamy, tangy filling that’s milder than some premium brands but still satisfying.
The olives are hand-stuffed with a focus on shape, color, and size — each olive is selected for uniformity. Customers appreciate the variety for entertaining, as the garlic and jalapeno options add different flavor profiles to a cocktail or appetizer tray. The brine is clean and not overly salty.
Jar size is the main limitation here. Each 5 oz jar is small, so this pack is best for a single gathering or to test which flavor you prefer before buying a larger quantity. The price per ounce is higher than buying a single flavor in a bigger jar.
Why it’s great
- Three distinct flavors for sampling or entertaining
- Hand-selected olives with consistent quality
- Clean, balanced brine
Good to know
- Small 5 oz jars — not for heavy use
- Higher cost per ounce versus bulk options
5. Divina Olives Stuffed With Blue Cheese in Brine (3-Pack)
This 3-pack of Divina’s blue cheese stuffed olives is essentially the same product as the 2-pack reviewed above, but in a larger bundle. Each 7.8 oz jar delivers the same firm Greek olives and generous blue cheese filling that customers love. For anyone who goes through olives quickly — or wants to stock a home bar — this is the most efficient way to buy.
The brine is flavorful enough to use directly in martinis, and the olives themselves are “large and meaty” according to repeat buyers. Several customers mention eating them straight from the jar as a snack, which is a good sign for the cheese quality.
The biggest risk is packaging: multiple customers report that one or two jars arrive unsealed or broken, with brine leaking into the box. Since food items are non-returnable, this is a significant frustration. Ordering from a seller with good packaging is essential.
Why it’s great
- Consistent quality across three jars — great value for heavy users
- Brine formula works perfectly in Dirty Martinis
- Large, meaty olives with a creamy center
Good to know
- Frequent reports of broken seals during shipping
- Not returnable if damaged — check seller packaging policies
6. Filthy Martini Cocktail Kit
This kit bundles Filthy’s Olive Brine, a jar of pimento-stuffed olives, a jar of blue cheese-stuffed olives, and four stainless steel cocktail picks. It’s everything you need to make a Dirty Martini from scratch, all in one box. The blue cheese olives are the same premium product as the standalone jar, so you get that same creamy Wisconsin blue cheese and firm Queen olive.
The included brine is a standout — customers love the flavor balance and use it not just for martinis but also for cooking (adding to pasta water or salad dressings). The stainless steel picks are a nice touch for presentation. Several buyers say this kit makes a great gift for cocktail lovers.
The only downside is that the kit is priced higher than buying the components individually, and you’re locked into Filthy’s specific brine recipe. If you prefer a different brine or already have picks, you might be paying for extras you don’t need.
Why it’s great
- All-in-one martini setup with premium ingredients
- Includes separate brining liquid for precise cocktail mixing
- Stainless steel picks add a touch of class
Good to know
- Premium price — not a budget option
- Kit contains only one jar of blue cheese olives
7. Pearls Specialties Blue Cheese Stuffed Greek Queen Olives (6-Pack)
Pearls is a 75-year-old American brand known for reliable quality. This 6-pack of 6.7 oz jars uses Halkidiki Queen olives imported from Greece, hand-stuffed with blue cheese. The olives are firm and mild, with a cheese that’s creamy but not overly pungent — a safe choice for guests who aren’t blue cheese fanatics.
Customers use these mainly for Dirty Martinis, praising the “best martini olives ever” and noting that the brine is well-balanced enough to drink straight. The price per jar when buying in bulk is competitive, making it a solid option for home bars that go through jars quickly. The olives are gluten-free and non-GMO.
Repeat buyers report that the blue cheese filling can sometimes separate from the olive during shipping, leading to some loose cheese in the jar. The 6-pack also takes up significant fridge space. But for the volume, this is the most practical bulk option for martini lovers.
Why it’s great
- Excellent value per jar when buying in bulk
- Reliable, family-owned brand with consistent quality
- Brine flavor ideal for Dirty Martinis fresh from the jar
Good to know
- Cheese can settle during shipping — shake jar before use
- 6 jars take up significant fridge real estate
FAQ
Can I use oil-packed blue cheese olives in a martini?
How should I store opened blue cheese stuffed olives?
What does “hand-stuffed” mean for olives?
Are blue cheese stuffed olives healthy for keto or low-carb diets?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best blue cheese stuffed olives winner is the Filthy Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives because it delivers the ideal creamy, tangy Wisconsin blue cheese center inside a firm, naturally cured Queen olive — everything a premium Dirty Martini garnish should be. If you want the best value for cabinet stocking, grab the Divina 2-Pack, which offers generous cheese filling and a solid brine punch. And for a charcuterie board showstopper, nothing beats the Tassos Colossal Olives — though remember they’re oil-packed and not for cocktail use.