Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
A blue eyeliner pencil can make your eye color pop, but the real challenge is finding one that glides on smoothly in the morning and still looks fresh after a long day, without smudging, fading, or turning into a raccoon-eye mess. Most options promise long wear, but the formula and pigment quality vary widely, so knowing which pencil actually delivers on that promise saves you time and frustration.
I’m Rikta — the founder and writer behind FitlyFast. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
if you need a subtle navy for the office or a sparkling blue for an evening look, this breakdown of the best blue eye pencil options will help you pick the one that matches your routine, budget, and desired intensity.
Quick Picks
- LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Kajal Longwear Kohl Eyeliner Pencil – Midnight Blue Kohl — Best Overall
- Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof, 5 Sparkling Blue — Luxury Pick
- SEPHORA COLLECTION Contour Eye Pencil 12hr Wear Waterproof 0.04 Oz 29 My Boyfriend’s Jeans – Electric Blue — Electric Edge
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Faux Blacks Eyeliner Pencil – Midnight (Navy Blue) — Budget Navy
- Westmore Beauty Lasting Effects Soft Glide Eyeliner – Waterproof & Smudge-Proof – Deep Navy — Gel Precision
- Radiant Professional Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil – Navy Blue (05) — Entry-Level Soft
How To Choose The Best Blue Eye Pencil
The main things to look at in a blue eye pencil are the formula type (kohl versus standard wax), the staying power (waterproof and smudge-proof claims backed by real wear), the color payoff in one stroke, and how easy it is to sharpen without breaking the tip.
Formula: Kohl, Gel, or Wax
A kohl pencil is very soft and blendable, making it ideal for the waterline and smoky looks. A gel formula is firmer and typically more waterproof, giving you a precise line that stays put. Standard wax pencils are a middle ground — creamy but may need more frequent sharpening.
Pigment and Finish
Blue shades range from deep navy to electric or sparkling. A highly pigmented pencil delivers rich color in a single swipe. The finish can be matte (pure color, no shine), semi-matte (slight sheen), or sparkling (with glitter particles), each suited to different occasions and eye looks.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Formula Type | Weight | Built-in Sharpener | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Laura Geller Kajal Longwear Kohl | All-day waterline wear | Kohl | 0.56 oz | Yes | $24.00Amazon |
| Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star | Luxury, waterproof precision | Retractable Gel | 0.21 oz | Yes | $75.00Amazon |
| SEPHORA COLLECTION Contour Eye Pencil | Electric blue color pop | Wax-based | 0.32 oz | No | $16.91Amazon |
| NYX Faux Blacks Eyeliner Pencil | Deep navy on a budget | Wax-based | — | No | $16.00Amazon |
| Westmore Beauty Soft Glide Eyeliner | Semi-matte precision | — | 0.32 oz | No | $24.00Amazon |
| Radiant Professional Waterproof Eyeliner | Budget-friendly soft navy | — | 0.63 oz | No | $16.99Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Kajal Longwear Kohl Eyeliner Pencil – Midnight Blue Kohl
$24.00as of Jul 5, 12:01 AMA soft kohl that sets fast enough to survive a teary afternoon commute.
The star here is the buttery kohl formula, which buyers report glides on smoothly without tugging and dries down quickly so it does not smudge. It is infused with Vitamin E and Caffeine to condition the skin while delivering vibrant color — a nice bonus if your eyelids are sensitive. The built-in sharpener in the end cap is a practical touch that saves you from hunting for a separate tool.
At 0.56 ounces versus the SEPHORA COLLECTION Contour Eye Pencil at 0.32 ounces, it gives you more product for your money. Owners mention that the pencil is “soft, glides on, dries fast to no-smudge,” which aligns with the rich pigment that shows up in one pass. The trade-off is that keeping a thin line requires frequent sharpening, as a few owners noted.
Why It Wins
- Kohl formula is soft and blendable for smoky looks
- Built-in sharpener is always ready
- Hydrating ingredients add comfort on the waterline
The Trade-Off
- Kohl softness makes keeping a thin line tricky
- Needs more frequent sharpening than wax pencils
Reach for this if: you want an all-day waterline liner that blends easily and comes with its own sharpener.
Look elsewhere if: you need a super-precise, razor-thin line without constant touch-ups.
2. Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof, 5 Sparkling Blue
$75.00as of Jul 5, 12:01 AMA retractable pencil that turns waterproof into a promise you can trust.
Sisley uses a creamy gel formula enriched with Rosehip Oil, Bisabolol, and Vitamin E acetate, so the tip glides on without dragging. The mechanism is retractable with an integrated sharpener, meaning you never deal with wood shavings or broken tips. Reviewers consistently call it “truly waterproof” — one noted it stays on the waterline “without running,” unlike many pencils that claim waterproof but fade by lunch.
One buyer who has used it for five years said it has “more intense pigment and smoother than Chanel.” The sparkling blue shade delivers a luminous shimmer that catches light without looking heavy. At a premium price point, it is a splurge, but owners say it is “worth the higher price” because it stays on through heat, humidity, and tears without budging.
The standout spec: Truly waterproof formula that customers note survives the waterline — the hardest test for any liner.
A fantastic choice for: anyone who wants a luxury pencil with intense pigment that lasts all day without running or smudging.
Not for you if: you prefer a matte finish or a non-sparkling look — this shade has delicate glitter.
3. SEPHORA COLLECTION Contour Eye Pencil 12hr Wear Waterproof 0.04 Oz 29 My Boyfriend’s Jeans – Electric Blue
$16.91as of Jul 5, 12:01 AMAn electric blue that fights off smudges and stays true all day.
This pencil delivers a bold electric blue that reviewers say “stays on well.” The 12-hour waterproof claim holds up in real wear — shoppers say it does not smear, even through curling lashes. It is a wax-based formula, so it is firmer than kohl, giving you more control for a defined line. The 0.04 oz net weight makes it compact, and the packaging measures 5.12 x 2.48 x 0.43 inches, while the NYX Faux Blacks pencil measures 0.36 x 5.23 x 0.36 inches.
The main catch buyers mention is that it can be “harder to remove” and needs frequent sharpening, so a good makeup remover (like an oil-based one) is necessary. A few owners also noted the presence of glitter in the formula, which might not be what you want for a matte day look. The brand offers Sephora quality at a mid-range price point, making it a reliable pick if you want a standout blue that does not budge.
The honest trade-off: fantastic staying power but requires effort to remove and has some sparkle — not for matte-only fans.
Best for: anyone who wants a vibrant, long-wearing electric blue that outlasts cheaper options.
Skip if: you dislike glittery finishes or need a pencil that removes quickly with just water.
4. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Faux Blacks Eyeliner Pencil – Midnight (Navy Blue)
$16.00as of Jul 5, 12:01 AMA navy that gives green eyes a lift while staying affordable.
NYX describes this as a deep matte navy, and buyers love that it enhances green eyes and provides a softer alternative to black or brown for work. The creamy formula goes on smooth and can be smudged out for a smoky look. At a budget-friendly price, it is a low-risk way to try a colored liner. One reviewer noted they bought six pencils because the color and staying power are great for the cost.
The biggest complaint, though, is sharpening. Several buyers report that the pencil “needs sharpening every other use” and the wood can scratch the skin if you do not use a quality sharpener. A few pencils arrived broken or the lead fell out during sharpening. The color is described by one reviewer as “a warm burnt sienna” rather than a true navy, so check the Midnight shade name closely. It also lacks a built-in sharpener, unlike the Laura Geller pencil.
What Shines
- Soft matte navy that flatters green eyes
- Great value, especially if you buy multiples
- Smudges well for a smoky eye look
What Gives
- Requires frequent sharpening with a good sharpener
- Some pencils arrive broken or the lead falls out
- Color may lean warm, not a true blue
Best for: budget-savvy shoppers who want a deep navy to try colored liner without a big investment.
Not ideal if: you need a precise, always-ready pencil — the sharpening hassle can be frustrating.
5. Westmore Beauty Lasting Effects Soft Glide Eyeliner – Waterproof & Smudge-Proof – Deep Navy
$24.00as of Jul 5, 12:01 AMA smooth eyeliner that stays on the waterline without tugging.
This pencil uses a soft formula that buyers describe as “very smooth” with “rich color” and truly non-smudge performance on the waterline. The semi-matte finish gives a modern look without heavy sparkle. One reviewer, who tried many waterlines, said “this one comes out close to the top of the line” because it goes on smooth and stays where you put it. That is high praise if you have struggled with pencils that fade or transfer.
The catch, reported by a few buyers, is that the color “only last a couple of hours after dusk,” meaning it may fade faster by evening. The 6.1 x 0.75 x 0.67 inch package is one size, while the Radiant Professional Waterproof pencil is 6.34 x 0.43 x 0.28 inches. If you need a pencil for all-day wear that starts in the morning and goes into the night, this fading issue is worth considering.
The key insight: perfect for daytime and waterline use, but expect a shorter lifespan if you are going out at night.
Grab this if: you want a smooth, non-tugging gel that truly stays on the waterline during the day.
Think twice if: you need the color to last from morning through late evening events.
6. Radiant Professional Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil – Navy Blue (05)
$16.99as of Jul 5, 12:01 AMA navy pencil that comes with a built-in smudger for smoky eyes.
This pencil is formulated with Vitamin E and jojoba oil, making it a nourishing option for contact lens wearers. The formula glides on smoothly and is marketed as waterproof and smudge proof. At 0.63 ounces versus the SEPHORA COLLECTION Contour Eye Pencil at 0.32 ounces, you are getting a lot of product for the price. The included smudger tool is handy for creating a smoky eye without needing extra brushes.
The honest feedback from buyers is mixed on longevity. While some love the smooth application and color, one review says “I really like the color but it fades quickly,” which is a common issue with softer gel formulas. Another buyer found the packaging extremely difficult to open, calling it “the most difficult packaging I have ever encountered” — the cap required boiling water to remove. The navy shade is soft and pretty, but if you need a liner that survives a full 12-hour day, this may not be the one.
The Good
- Smooth gel with nourishing ingredients for sensitive eyes
- Includes a smudger tool for smoky looks
- Generous 0.63 oz of product
The Not-So-Good
- Color fades faster than other waterproof pencils
- Packaging can be extremely difficult to open
- Soft formula may not hold tight lines all day
Good for: a budget-friendly soft navy if you prioritize smooth glide and smudging over all-day staying power.
Avoid if: you need a pencil that lasts from morning to night without fading or reapplying.
Understanding the Specs
Kohl vs Wax vs Gel Formula
The formula determines how the pencil feels on your eye. A kohl formula (like the Laura Geller) is very soft and creamy, perfect for smudging and applying to the waterline, but it may require more frequent sharpening. A wax-based formula (like the SEPHORA COLLECTION) is firmer, giving you a more precise line and longer wear. Some pencils are marketed simply as soft or smooth formulas rather than clearly labeled kohl, wax, or gel. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize blendability or precision.
Built-in Sharpener
A pencil with a built-in sharpener in the end cap (like the Laura Geller and Sisley Paris pencils) saves you from needing a separate tool. Without it, you rely on a standard sharpener, and some pencils (like the NYX Faux Blacks) are prone to breaking or losing the lead if the sharpener is not high quality. For daily use, a built-in sharpener is a convenience that keeps your pencil ready to go.
FAQ
Can I use a blue eye pencil on my waterline?
How do I sharpen a blue eye pencil without breaking it?
What does waterproof mean for an eyeliner pencil?
Is a kohl pencil better for smoky eyes than a gel pencil?
How long does a blue eye pencil last before it runs out?
Do blue eye pencils work on all eye colors?
What is the difference between matte, semi-matte, and sparkling finishes?
Can I use a blue eye pencil if I wear contact lenses?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most buyers, the blue eye pencil winner is the Laura Geller Kajal Longwear Kohl because it combines a soft, blendable formula with a built-in sharpener and hydrating ingredients — perfect for all-day waterline wear. If you want a luxurious, truly waterproof pencil with a sparkling finish and intense pigment, grab the Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star. And for a budget-friendly deep navy that gives green eyes a lift, the NYX Faux Blacks Eyeliner Pencil is a solid entry-level pick.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of July 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, FitlyFast earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED "AS IS" AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.